Recent Reviews
The Cap'ns Slice
Jessica Nusbaum : 5 on 6/6/2025 1:31 pm
Absolutely love this place! Delicious, unique pizzas and awesome staff. The slices reheat well at home, so don’t be afraid to get extra for leftovers. I’ve been getting pizza from here for about a year and will definitely keep coming back!
Jessica Nusbaum
1749216683
5
5
The Cap'ns Slice
Bethany Hart : 5 on 8/21/2025 6:10 pm
The best pizza you can get in the area. Fresh ingredients, unique flavor combinations, and the ability to try an array of different slices make this a must-try. Worth the trip to Berlin for this pizza, you won’t be disappointed with everything this town has to offer.
Bethany Hart
1755799806
5
5
The Cap'ns Slice
Tati Kuzminski : 5 on 8/10/2025 11:23 pm
Outstanding slice of pizza. That coming from a North Jersey gal. The crust was cooked just right, thin crust style, crunchy end on crust and chewy, nice size slice. Pesto was not overpowering. Plentiful pepperoni and it was not that greasy. This was a re- heated slice that tasted fresh out of the oven! Very good tasting pizza. Very small place with stools against the wall and window. Service was great. I highly recommend it.
Tati Kuzminski
1754868216
5
5
The Cap'ns Slice
Modal title